The idea of an authenticity index is explored in this chapter as a concept that illustrates how audiences productively work through frictions. Friction is a metaphor for thinking through instabilities across factual and reality genres, streaming platforms and knowledge systems. An authenticity index operates a little like the financial markets in the sense that audiences trade in truth claims and judge authenticity according to fluctuating value markers. Using interviews with audiences in the Nordic streaming environment, the value markers of recommendation, somatic evidence and storytelling are analysed as indicators of such an index. The chapter situates an authenticity index in the broader context of post-referentiality, an absence of stability in facts, experts and evidence from traditional knowledge and media systems.