The Impact of Digitalization on Profitability and Efficiency in European Banking: A Pre and Post COVID Analysis
2026 (English)Independent thesis Advanced level (degree of Master (One Year)), 40 credits / 60 HE credits
Student thesis
Abstract [en]
This study examines how the COVID-19 pandemic affected the profitability and operational efficiency of large listed European banks. The analysis is based on a balanced semi-annual panel of large listed commercial banks across thirteen EU member states, observed from the second half of 2018 to the first half of 2024. The pandemic is represented by two distinct phases: an acute phase covering the onset of the crisis and the near-zero interest rate environment, and a post-acute phase covering the subsequent period of monetary tightening. Bank performance is captured through return on assets and net interest margin as profitability indicators and through the cost-to-income ratio as an efficiency indicator. Bank performance is captured through return on assets and net interest margin as profitability indicators and through the cost-to-income ratio as an efficiency indicator. Efficiency in this study refers specifically to operational cost efficiency - the operating expenses a bank incurs per unit of operating income - measured by the cost-to-income ratio (CIR), so that a lower ratio denotes greater efficiency. Bank size, the short-term policy rate, non-performing loans and the country-level level of digital adoption are included as control variables. PSD2 is treated as part of the digitalisation background rather than as an estimated treatment, because the harmonised supervisory data begin at almost the same time as the directive entered into force, leaving no clean pre-PSD2 period against which its effect could be identified. The results show that the acute phase of the pandemic was associated with a clear deterioration in both profitability and interest margins. In the post-acute phase, profitability recovered in raw terms, but this recovery disappears once the policy rate is held constant, which indicates that the rebound was driven mainly by the interest rate cycle rather than by the pandemic itself. Efficiency, by contrast, shows no significant deterioration during the acute phase but a lasting improvement afterwards, consistent with the view that pandemic-era digital investment durably lowered the operating cost base. A comparison between banks operating in more and less digitally mature environments suggests that less digitally advanced banks experienced the sharpest profitability losses during the acute phase and achieved the largest efficiency gains afterwards, while more digitally advanced banks changed relatively little, a pattern consistent with a ceiling effect. This study examines how the COVID-19 pandemic affected the profitability and operational efficiency of large listed European banks. The analysis is based on a balanced semi-annual panel of large listed commercial banks across thirteen EU member states, observed from the second half of 2018 to the first half of 2024. The pandemic is represented by two distinct phases: an acute phase covering the onset of the crisis and the near-zero interest rate environment, and a post-acute phase covering the subsequent period of monetary tightening. Bank performance is captured through return on assets and net interest margin as profitability indicators and through the cost-to-income ratio as an efficiency indicator. Bank performance is captured through return on assets and net interest margin as profitability indicators and through the cost-to-income ratio as an efficiency indicator. Efficiency in this study refers specifically to operational cost efficiency - the operating expenses a bank incurs per unit of operating income - measured by the cost-to-income ratio (CIR), so that a lower ratio denotes greater efficiency. Bank size, the short-term policy rate, non-performing loans and the country-level level of digital adoption are included as control variables. PSD2 is treated as part of the digitalisation background rather than as an estimated treatment, because the harmonised supervisory data begin at almost the same time as the directive entered into force, leaving no clean pre-PSD2 period against which its effect could be identified. The results show that the acute phase of the pandemic was associated with a clear deterioration in both profitability and interest margins. In the post-acute phase, profitability recovered in raw terms, but this recovery disappears once the policy rate is held constant, which indicates that the rebound was driven mainly by the interest rate cycle rather than by the pandemic itself. Efficiency, by contrast, shows no significant deterioration during the acute phase but a lasting improvement afterwards, consistent with the view that pandemic-era digital investment durably lowered the operating cost base. A comparison between banks operating in more and less digitally mature environments suggests that less digitally advanced banks experienced the sharpest profitability losses during the acute phase and achieved the largest efficiency gains afterwards, while more digitally advanced banks changed relatively little, a pattern consistent with a ceiling effect. Overall, the findings indicate that an abrupt and exogenous shock such as COVID-19 leaves a clearer and more identifiable signature on bank performance than gradual regulatory change, with implications for how supervisors interpret and calibrate future digital regulation such as DORA and FiDA.
Place, publisher, year, edition, pages
2026. , p. 35
Keywords [en]
Finance, Analysis, CIR, NIM, ROA, Banking, Europe, COVID
National Category
Economics and Business
Identifiers
URN: urn:nbn:se:hj:diva-73686OAI: oai:DiVA.org:hj-73686DiVA, id: diva2:2095928
Supervisors
Examiners
2026-09-162026-08-272026-09-16Bibliographically approved